27 Comments
User's avatar
Bernadette Bradley's avatar

Definitely a ladler of dodgy alphabet soup. I like the cauldron connotation. Conjures up pictures of people, especially women stirring things up😀

Expand full comment
Jack Bishop's avatar

I've had the most awful day and this has cheered me a little, so thanks for that. I live relatively near to Ledbury, so might have to seek it out this year!

Expand full comment
Denis Mildon's avatar

Once again, enjoyed this immensely but hardly a surprise, I know who is writing this, I think.

Expand full comment
Jill's avatar

That’s not alphabet soup; it’s a Michelin-starred alphabet consommé. Thank you. 🙏

Expand full comment
Max Christie's avatar

This was swell, madam. In general I like the spectator role bc it makes for a more convenient way to head for the hills, or forest, or wherever else the haven might be. My inner cav is likely to knock my inner roundhead off his humble donkey onto his pompous ass, but my inner roundhead has a few steadying words for the intoxicated cav.

Expand full comment
Sarah Donoghue's avatar

Oh Margaret! What a joyous read! I would always be the one on the sidelines serving the refreshments any day of the week. I've always had a secret penchant for this sort of caper. I can't think of a more enjoyable day than dressing up, then having a good old debate in a pub. Thankyou for sharing your adventures.

Expand full comment
George Green's avatar

A lovely surprise to see a familiar placename featured in your newsletter. It's local to us (we are in rich battle reenactment land, near Evesham, Tewkesbury and Ledbury). My mum taught at Tewkesbury comprehensive school. In the 1990s, she had a class she referred to affectionately as 'the hooligans'. She won them over when they asked which Rose she supporeted, Miss, and must have answered right.

Expand full comment
Charles  Brent's avatar

So tasty with the perfect amount of oregano (wish my mushy South Africans get educated to change the ANC alphabet 🤗)

Expand full comment
Andrew Paul Koole's avatar

I'd like to say I'm an alphabet soup doler, but if i'm being honest, more often than not, I'm a Mushy Middle spectator. But I'm looking to you cauldron stirrers to convert me to your ways.

Expand full comment
Jane Pine's avatar

I’m pretty sure I’m a Mushy Middler with a lean towards the soup cauldron. Another delightful read! Thank you for brightening my morning.

Expand full comment
Max Christie's avatar

Given the neckline, gotta be Cavalier

Expand full comment
Martha Bowden's avatar

I think Roundhead, because of the severity of the style and the black colour palette. I’ll see if I can attach this image of Oliver Cromwell’s wife. https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/976/mcs/media/images/79518000/jpg/_79518469_af030f0d-5188-4374-a2a5-b62402c35940.jpg Nope, just the link. Google “Elizabeth Cromwell, Oliver’s wife.

Expand full comment
Max Christie's avatar

Whoa, that’s a great comparison!

Expand full comment
Martha Bowden's avatar

I wonder if it was the model for this young woman’s dress? She is, however, in a quite characteristic dress for women of the Parliamentary party. The Royalists went for much more flamboyant colours, more fabric generally, and much bigger hair.

Expand full comment
Max Christie's avatar

When I consider the palate, especially, it is obvious, or at least seems so. I guess my modern brain applied a kind of expectation of a more severe puritanical modesty about cut, but seeing Mme Cromwell’s look, that doesn’t make much sense.

Expand full comment
Steve Chapple's avatar

Terrifically amusing and thoughtful as usual. I'm a left-wing Cavalier. Oh, oh.

Expand full comment
Steve's avatar

Darn entertaining. I love your writing, Ms Atwood.

Expand full comment
Thomas D’Arcy O’Donnell's avatar

Wondrous ! Semper Fi eh ! Hup two three four.. & Huzza !

Expand full comment
Chris Speechly's avatar

All hail ye olde mushy middle! A place well insulated from the harsh and dangerous screams of the self-righteous Roundheads and the condescending sniffs of the pompous Cavaliers. Beg, borrow and steal from each while owing neither allegiance nor affection to either.

Expand full comment
joe medjuck's avatar

Wasn't there (as usual) a religious component to this battle?

Expand full comment
Grant McPhail's avatar

Best political commentary in a long time.

Expand full comment